From the people you love to the dreams you’re building, your world deserves thoughtful protection. Let’s explore insurance options that work for you.
70+ years of local perspective.
A lot has changed since we first opened our doors in 1948—but our dedication to the community hasn’t. We always continue to grow, serving the Indianapolis region with care and attention. We take time to listen and help guide you through your options, all while working with respected regional and national carriers.
Rooted in the Circle City.
Being based in Indianapolis, IN, means more than just a zip code—it means knowing our neighbors and building lasting relationships. At McClain Matthews Insurance, we blend big-picture thinking with homegrown values. Our focus? Helping clients explore coverage in a way that feels approachable and informed.
Our Mission
Protecting Your Future Starts Today
Since 1948, McClain Matthews Insurance has worked with Indiana communities to offer thoughtful insurance choices and support. Our mission is to provide approachable service, meaningful relationships, and experienced guidance.
Request QuoteMeet Our Owner
Reliable Protection,
Prepared for Your Needs
At McClain Matthews Insurance, we offer a wide range of personal insurance, business insurance, and insurance by industry coverage options. Our goal is to help you safeguard what matters most.
Let’s Get Started
Request an Insurance Quote
"*" indicates required fields
Don’t like forms? Contact us at or .
